Andy’s Menu With Prices

At Andy’s Frozen Custard, you’ll find fresh custard in cups, cones, sundaes, concretes, and Jackhammers priced between $4 and $9.

Choose from classic flavors like vanilla and Oreo®, plus seasonal specials.

Customize your treat with free or premium toppings to suit your taste and budget.

Their loyalty program rewards your visits with free treats and perks.

Whether you want a quick snack or a shareable dessert, there’s something flavorful and affordable waiting for you.

Keep exploring to discover the best picks and savings.

Key Takeaways

• Concretes and Jackhammers range from $4.49 to $6.49, featuring customizable layered dessert options.
• Classic sundaes cost between $4.99 and $6.29, with shareable splits priced from $6.49 to $9.
• Cups and cones come in small, regular, and large sizes, with prices varying by size and toppings.
• Seasonal specials like Cookie Casanova and Strawberry Cheesecake range from $4.50 to $6.00.
• Malts, shakes, and old-fashioned freezes are priced between $4 and $6 depending on size and extras.

Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu Highlights and Pricing

While exploring Andy’s Frozen Custard menu, you’ll find a tempting selection of concretes, sundaes, splits, and frozen beverages, all customizable to your taste. Their frozen custard concretes stand out, with favorites like the BootDaddy, Triple Chocolate, and Snowmonster ranging from $4.49 to $6.49.

If you prefer something classic, the signature sundaes such as Andy’s Ozark Turtle and Hot Fudge Sundae typically cost between $4.99 and $6.29. Looking for a shareable treat? Andy’s Banana Split and Turtle Split are great options, usually priced around $6.49.

Don’t miss out on their frozen beverages, including malts, shakes, and old-fashioned freezes, which you can enjoy for $4.29 to $6.29. Andy’s menu prices offer great variety and value, making it easy to find a frozen custard dessert that suits your cravings and budget perfectly.

Cups and Cones: Custard Flavors and Prices

You’ll find fresh chocolate and vanilla custard served hourly in cups or cones—waffle and sugar cones included. Just pick your favorite flavor and go ahead, customize it with a bunch of tasty toppings. Prices vary depending on the size and the toppings you choose, so it’s easy to grab a quick treat that’s just right for you.

Flavor Options Available

Because Andy’s makes its custard fresh every hour, you can enjoy a variety of rich flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and Oreo®, served in cups or cones. Their frozen custard is known for its creamy texture, and the flavor options don’t stop there.

You’ll find seasonal and limited-time flavors that keep your choices exciting throughout the year. Whether you prefer classic tastes or something new, Andy’s lets you customize your treat with multiple toppings to suit your cravings.

Prices for cups and cones vary by size, giving you flexibility when ordering. When you’re at Andy’s, you’re not just picking a dessert; you’re choosing from a wide range of fresh, delicious frozen custard flavor options tailored just for you.

Serving Styles Offered

Andy’s serves its fresh, creamy custard in both cups and cones, giving you flexible options to enjoy your favorite flavors. You can choose from vanilla or chocolate, made fresh every hour to guarantee quality.

Whether you prefer a small, medium, or large size, Andy’s has cups and cones to fit your craving and appetite. These individual servings are perfect for a quick treat on the go.

If you want to personalize your custard, you can add a variety of toppings for an extra cost, enhancing your experience. Convenient and delicious, the custard cups and cones let you savor fresh, flavorful custard anytime, making it easy to satisfy your sweet tooth wherever you are.

Hourly Freshness Guarantee

Although custard is a simple treat, its quality depends on freshness. That’s why Andy’s prepares cups and cones every hour. This hourly freshness guarantee means you’ll always get custard at its peak, made fresh right in the kitchen.

Whether you prefer classic vanilla, rich chocolate, or one of the rotating flavors, you can trust that every scoop is carefully crafted for superior taste. You can enjoy your custard in a cup or cone, choosing from small, regular, or large sizes—all priced accordingly.

Concretes: Signature Blended Custard Treats and Costs

When you crave a rich, spoonable dessert, concretes deliver by blending creamy frozen custard with your choice of mix-ins and toppings. These signature treats come in tempting varieties like BootDaddy, Triple Chocolate, Ooey Gooey, Snowmonster, and Butter Pecan concretes. Each offers a unique flavor experience.

You can also customize your concrete by adding extra toppings for a small additional charge, giving you the freedom to create a personalized indulgence. Prices for concretes typically range from $4 to $6, depending on the size and any customization you choose.

These desserts stand out because of their thick, creamy texture and the way the mix-ins are fully blended into the frozen custard, making every spoonful rich and satisfying. Enjoying a concrete means savoring a perfectly balanced dessert that’s both smooth and packed with flavor, ideal for anyone who loves frozen custard with a twist.

Jackhammers: Rich Filled Concretes and Pricing

If you love the creamy texture of concretes, Jackhammers take that indulgence a step further by adding rich, customizable filling centers. These rich filled concretes offer a layered dessert experience where you can choose your own center, making each Jackhammer uniquely yours.

For example, the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer blends frozen custard with peanut butter, brownies, and hot fudge for a decadent treat. The Rico Suave Jackhammer features vanilla or chocolate custard combined with roasted pecans, Oreos®, and a hot fudge core.

Here’s a quick look at some popular Jackhammers and their prices:

Jackhammer Flavor	Price
James Brownie Funky	$6.49
Rico Suave (Vanilla/Choc)	$6.29
Custom Filled Jackhammer	$6.59

Dive into these rich filled concretes for a truly indulgent, layered flavor experience.

Sundaes: Classic Frozen Custard Sundaes and Prices

Since you crave classic frozen custard sundaes, Andy’s offers a tempting lineup featuring favorites like the Ozark Turtle, Tin Roof, and Original Straw-Ana. Each sundae highlights rich frozen custard paired with delicious toppings.

The Ozark Turtle Sundae tops frozen custard with hot fudge, crème caramel, roasted pecans, and a cherry for a perfect blend of flavors. If you love a crunch, the Tin Roof Sundae combines frozen custard with chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts, delivering a satisfying texture.

For a fruity twist, the Original Straw-Ana Sundae mixes frozen custard with fresh strawberries and sliced bananas. Don’t miss the Stolen Brownie Sundae, where a warm brownie meets frozen custard, hot fudge, pecans, and a cherry, creating a decadent treat.

Each sundae offers a classic taste of frozen custard with rich hot fudge or complementary toppings, making Andy’s sundaes a go-to for your sweet cravings.

Splits: Banana and Turtle Splits With Price Options

Andy’s sundaes satisfy your sweet tooth, and their splits take that indulgence up a notch with generous portions and fresh ingredients. When you order a banana split, you get frozen custard paired with a whole banana, strawberries, marshmallow crème, crushed nuts, and a cherry on top.

If you’re craving something richer, the turtle split combines frozen custard, banana, hot fudge, crème caramel, pecans, and a cherry for a decadent treat. Both splits offer customization options that let you add extra toppings to match your tastes, making them perfect for sharing or savoring solo.

Prices typically range from $7 to $9, depending on your choices.

Consider these benefits when choosing your split:

• Fresh, quality ingredients guarantee every bite is satisfying
• Generous portions make it a great option for sharing
• Customizable toppings let you craft your perfect dessert experience

With these splits, you’re in for a deliciously memorable treat.

Seasonal Specials: Limited-Time Treats and Prices

When you’re craving something fresh and exciting, seasonal specials offer limited-time treats like Cookie Casanova, Strawberry Cheesecake, and Blueberry that rotate monthly. These seasonal specials showcase unique flavors and toppings you won’t find on the regular menu, adding variety and a sense of exclusivity.

Prices for these limited-time treats typically range from $4.50 to $6.00, depending on the size and toppings you choose. Andy’s carefully designs these offerings to celebrate holidays and changing seasons, making each visit a chance to try something new and festive.

You’ll often see these specials promoted both in-store and on social media, so you won’t miss out. If you want a fresh twist on your favorite dessert, keep an eye on Andy’s seasonal specials. They’re the perfect way to enjoy limited-time flavors before they disappear.

Malts, Shakes & Old-Fashioned Freezes Prices

Malts and shakes blend frozen custard with malt powder, toppings, or other ingredients to create creamy, layered treats you’ll love. At Andy’s, you’ll find these delicious malts and shakes priced between $4 and $6, depending on size and the extras you choose.

Malts and shakes mix frozen custard with malt powder and toppings for rich, creamy delights starting at $4.

If you want something a bit different, try their Old-Fashioned Freezes. These fizzy beverages mix custard with soda, offering an invigorating twist on classic soda floats, usually around $4 per serving.

Here’s what makes these options stand out:

• Malts and shakes come in flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and unique specialty blends.
• Old-Fashioned Freezes combine creamy custard with fizzy soda for a light, bubbly treat.
• Prices remain reasonable, letting you enjoy rich, flavorful drinks without breaking the bank.

Whether you crave a thick malt or a fizzy freeze, Andy’s menu has a tasty option waiting for you.

Frozen Custard Take-Home Options: Quart Combos and More

You can take Andy’s frozen custard home with Quart Combo™ packages that include a quart of vanilla or chocolate custard plus two toppings. If you want a little more variety, try the Pick 6 option—it comes with six half-pint cups in different flavors. These options make it super easy to enjoy your favorite custard anytime you want.

Quart Combo Details

Although you might be tempted to enjoy frozen custard immediately, Andy’s Quart Combo™ offers a perfect take-home solution. It lets you savor a quart of vanilla or chocolate custard paired with two toppings of your choice.

This quart combo is designed for convenience, letting you enjoy your favorite flavors at home or share with friends and family. You can customize your quart combo with a variety of toppings, such as candies, fruits, and nuts, to create your ideal treat.

With Andy’s quart combo, you get:

• A generous quart of creamy frozen custard in vanilla or chocolate
• Two customizable toppings to suit your taste
• A portable option perfect for sharing or savoring slowly

This makes the quart combo a versatile and delicious frozen custard option.

Take-Home Flavor Options

Beyond the Quart Combo™, Andy’s makes it easy to take your favorite frozen custard home with their Pick 6 option, which lets you choose six half-pint cups of various flavors. Whether you love classic vanilla, rich chocolate, Oreo®, or seasonal specials, you’ll find plenty of take-home flavors to satisfy your cravings.

The quart combo packages include a quart of vanilla or chocolate custard paired with two toppings, perfect for a ready-to-enjoy dessert. If you want to customize your take-home treats, you can add extra toppings to the Pick 6 cups or quart combos, making every bite uniquely yours.

These frozen custard take-home options are designed for easy storage and enjoyment anytime, so you can indulge in Andy’s creamy goodness whenever you want.

Toppings and Add-Ons: Enhance Your Dessert Affordably

How can you make your dessert even more delightful without breaking the bank? At Andy’s, toppings and add-ons let you customize your treat to match your cravings while keeping costs low. Many popular toppings like almonds, bananas, and chocolate chips come at no extra charge, so you can enhance flavor and texture effortlessly.

For a little extra, you can opt for premium add-ons that make your dessert feel special without considerably increasing the price.

These affordable enhancements work great with sundaes, concretes, splits, shakes, and malts. You get to tailor each dessert exactly how you like it, making each visit a unique experience.

Consider these benefits when adding toppings and add-ons: boost flavor and texture with fresh, tasty options, customize your dessert to suit your personal taste, and enjoy premium choices without a hefty price increase.

With these affordable choices, you’ll always leave Andy’s completely satisfied.

Andy’s Frozen Custard Loyalty Program Benefits and Savings

When you join Andy’s Frozen Custard Loyalty Program, you reveal a variety of perks designed to reward your love for their delicious treats. Right after your first visit, you’ll enjoy a free Small One-Topping Concrete, a perfect introduction to their creamy frozen custard.

Every time you purchase a treat, you earn points that add up toward a $5 reward, helping you save on future visits. Plus, loyalty members get a free iced tea on Tuesdays with any $5 minimum purchase, making your experience even more invigorating.

The program offers exclusive benefits and promotional offers you won’t find anywhere else, encouraging you to come back often and enjoy more of Andy’s frozen custard favorites. By joining, you maximize your savings while indulging in high-quality desserts, making every visit more rewarding.

This loyalty program truly values your patronage and sweet tooth.

Affordable Order Customization Tips

You can make your order unique without spending more by using loyalty rewards to save on customizations. Plus, keep an eye out for value combos that include your favorite toppings at a great price. And don’t forget to try seasonal toppings—they add excitement without any extra cost.

Maximize Loyalty Rewards

Although customizing your order might seem like it adds extra cost, joining Andy’s Loyalty program lets you enhance your treats affordably while earning points toward rewards. You get a free Small One-Topping Concrete after your first visit, making it easy to enjoy a personalized treat without extra charges.

Plus, earning loyalty rewards means you can redeem points for discounts on future orders, maximizing your value.

Here’s how to maximize your rewards:

• Redeem your points for a $5 reward to save on customized orders.
• Take advantage of free iced tea every Tuesday with a $5 minimum purchase.
• Add seasonal toppings during promotions for extra flavor without heavy costs.

Using these tips, you’ll enjoy tasty, budget-friendly upgrades every time.

Choose Value Combos

Since value combos at Andy’s include options like a quart of custard with two toppings or a half-pint featuring six flavors, they offer a smart way to customize your order without overspending. You can mix and match different frozen custard flavors and toppings within these value combos, tailoring your treat just how you like it.

Choosing a smaller custard size paired with toppings lets you enjoy a personalized dessert without breaking the bank. Plus, many value combos let you add seasonal or specialty toppings at a lower cost, enhancing your experience affordably.

Don’t forget to use loyalty rewards on value combos to save even more, making frozen custard customization both budget-friendly and delicious every time you visit Andy’s.

Customize With Seasonal Toppings

When looking to enhance your frozen custard without overspending, adding seasonal toppings at Andy’s offers an affordable and flavorful option. These toppings let you customize your custard blended treat with fresh, limited-time flavors that won’t break the bank.

Instead of choosing pricier dessert options, pick a simple cone or cup and boost its taste with seasonal toppings that add excitement and uniqueness.

Consider these tips for affordable customization:

• Opt for basic custard blended flavors and add a few seasonal toppings to keep costs low.
• Take advantage of promotional deals or loyalty rewards for free or discounted seasonal toppings.
• Choose fresh fruits or holiday-themed candies to create a festive, budget-friendly treat.

Seasonal toppings make your custard blended experience both unique and wallet-friendly.

Best Value Picks on Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu for Every Budget

If you’re looking to enjoy Andy’s Frozen Custard without breaking the bank, you’ll find plenty of options that deliver great taste and value. The Pick 6 deal is a standout, offering six half-pints of frozen custard at an affordable price, perfect for sharing or savoring later.

Small-sized concretes and sundaes give you classic flavors without overspending. Don’t miss the Quart Combo™, which lets you customize a quart of custard with multiple toppings for a reasonable price, ideal for those who love variety.

Plus, keep an eye out for limited time seasonal and daily specials. They often feature promotional pricing that makes indulging easier on your wallet. If you’re a regular, joining the loyalty program is a smart move; after your first visit, you earn a free small concrete, adding even more value.

Andy’s menu truly offers delicious treats for every budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are Andy’s Store Hours and Locations?

You’ll find Andy’s store hours typically run from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM daily, but these can vary by location. With ongoing store expansion across states like Missouri and Illinois, you’ve got plenty of spots to enjoy their seasonal flavors.

Since hours might shift during holidays or events, it’s smart to check the specific store’s schedule before visiting. Use their website’s store locator to find the nearest Andy’s and plan your visit accordingly.

Does Andy’s Offer Dairy-Free or Vegan Options?

No, Andy’s doesn’t offer dairy-free options for their frozen custard since it’s made with dairy. However, you can find some vegan toppings that might suit your needs if you’re looking to customize your treat.

If you want to enjoy something vegan, you’ll probably need to focus on those toppings or ask the store directly about any special accommodations. Keep in mind, the custard itself isn’t vegan or dairy-free.

Are There Any Allergen Warnings for Custard Ingredients?

Allergen information dances like a spotlight on Andy’s custard stage, ensuring ingredient transparency shines bright for you. You’ll find warnings for common allergens like dairy, eggs, and soy woven into each flavor’s story.

Since custard is made fresh hourly, cross-contact might sneak in, so you should always check labels or ask staff. Andy’s keeps safety center stage, helping you enjoy every creamy bite without a worry.

Can I Place Catering Orders for Events?

Yes, you can place catering orders for events, and you’ll love the catering customization options available. You can choose from a variety of event menu options like concretes, sundaes, splits, and shakes to suit your occasion.

Just make sure to order in advance by contacting your local store or customer service. This way, you can create a dessert spread tailored perfectly to your guests’ tastes and event needs.

Is There a Mobile App for Ordering Andy’s Custard?

Yes, you can order Andy’s custard through their mobile app. The app features easy menu browsing, customization options, and seamless ordering.

You’ll also earn loyalty points and access exclusive deals right from your phone. App user reviews highlight its convenience and smooth interface, making your ordering experience faster and more enjoyable.

You can download it on iOS or Android and start customizing your favorite treats with just a few taps.

Conclusion

You might think Andy’s Frozen Custard is pricey, but it’s actually a great value for the quality and variety you get. With affordable add-ons and customizable options, you can enjoy a delicious treat without breaking the bank.

Plus, their loyalty program helps you save even more over time. So go ahead, treat yourself! You’ll find that indulging in Andy’s menu is both satisfying and budget-friendly.